Tim ([info]bavariankumquat) wrote,

Heaven's Gate

Wow, what an utterly massive failure. It just utterly failed to connect, or even provide entertaining spectacle. Instead, we got ugly sepia toned action occuring with utterly incomprehensible sound, and really no characters at all that we could connect with. It again makes the huge mistake of making a movie about a historical event without having a character who is actually involved in it, instead involving a character who just sort of watches. So, instead of getting an account of an atrocity in American history where aspiring immigrants get horribly slaughtered from the point of view of one of the immigrants, which would have been interesting, we get token boring native born white guy who just sort of watches, And lots of immigrants just sort of saying incomprehensible dialogue, and lots of dialogue that is unhearable through the dolbyized foley of the soundtrack. Oh, and lots of dust. Thank you, Micheal Cimiono, for killing 70's auteur cinema, and also utterly destroying an awesome, artist-focused studio(aka United Artists). I hear the Deer Hunter sucks too.

  • Post a new comment

    Error

  • 3 comments

[info]erdbeermund

July 20 2005, 16:49:54 UTC 6 years ago

The Deer Hunter is amazing.

[info]bavariankumquat

July 20 2005, 18:18:42 UTC 6 years ago

Hmm, I guess I have heard both arguments, some people utterly love that movie and some people utterly hate it. I will be seeing it fairly soon once my friends get it from netflix, I am intrigued to see what got them to fund Heaven's Gate sight unseen. If you do end up watching Heaven's Gate, which is interesting on a level of utterly failing to connect and rampant epic filmmaking out of control, you should also read the book about the making of it, Final Cut, which details how exactly the movie became the huge disaster that it did. It just adds so much to the viewing of the movie to know how decisions were made behind the scenes, like how everyone hated Isabelle Huppert being cast except Micheal, and how the first rough cut of the movie ran five hours long.

[info]erdbeermund

July 21 2005, 01:08:56 UTC 6 years ago

Do you have the cable network Trio?
They often air this documentary about the making of Heaven's Gate alongside some kind of director's cut version of the film.

I never really gave the film too much of a chance though. The documentary is pretty interesting, but the film seemed on the dull side. I really wanted to enjoy it, but it didn't really seem like my kind of story.
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…